Ranking the AL East rotations - Through The Fence Baseball

Ranking the AL East rotations

by Thomas Fitzgerald | Posted on Monday, February 27th, 2012
| 877 baseball fanatics read this article

CC Sabathia is the anchor of a very deep New York rotation. (AP photo)

Pitching wins championships. We hear it all the time. Earl Weaver said, “Nobody likes to hear it, because it’s dull, but the reason you win or lose is darn near always the same — pitching.”  It’s the football equivalent of defense wins championships. While not always 100 percent true, there’s a reason fans agonize over pitching — have you heard it before?  It’s because it wins championships.

So, which AL East pitching staff has what it takes to make a deep run this season?  Let’s take a look from best to worst:

1. Yankees

2. Rays

3. Red Sox

4. Blue Jays

5. Orioles


The Yankees have the best starting rotation in the East going into the 2012 season. January 13, 2012, was a great day for Brian Cashman: He acquired 6-foot-7-inch possible future ace Michael Pineda from Seattle and signed free agent Hiroki Kuroda. Pineda is only 23 years old and has nasty stuff. As a rookie last season, Pineda posted a 9-10 record with an ERA of 3.74. He struck out 173 batters and walked only 55. Even though he’s now pitching in a tough AL East, expect a vast improvement on that 9-10 record even if his ERA rises a little. The only question is how Pineda will respond to pressure of pitching in New York. Cashman singed free-agent Kuroda to a one-year deal. Kuroda is 37 years old but still has it. Last season with the Dodgers, he posted an impressive 3.07 ERA while eating up 202 innings. Along with ace CC Sabathia, the Yankees have a formidable top of the rotation. Ivan Nova, Phil Hughes and Freddy Garcia will fill out what looks to be best pitching staff in the East. We list Hughes and Garcia as five and six but they will battle for the final spot in the rotation this spring.

Projected rotation:

  1. Sabathia
  2. Kuroda
  3. Pineda
  4. Nova (fourth in Rookie of The Year voting in 2011)
  5. Hughes
  6. Garcia (2011 stats: 12-8 with a 3.62 ERA)
Competing with big media markets and high spenders, the Rays can easily fly under the radar. But their pitching staff can’t. It’s filthy. Starting pitching is Tampa Bay’s biggest asset in 2012. David Price is the ace of this dominant starting five and went 12-13 with a 3.49 ERA last season. He had 218 SOs in 224.1 innings pitched. His ERA and record were disappointing for an ace, but there’s no reason to believe he won’t get to back his 2010 numbers where he posted a 19-6 record with 2.72 ERA. James Shields was an absolute force last season. Shields led the league in CGs with 11 and tossed four shutouts. He posted a 2.82 ERA in 249.1 innings pitched. Those numbers really came out of nowhere. From 2006-10 he had a total of five CGs and two shutouts. He more than doubled those numbers in 2011. It remains to be seen if he can match his spectacular 2011 campaign. Jeremy Hellickson won Rookie of the Year last season. He won it by going 13-10 while posting a 2.95 ERA. There’s no reason to believe Hellickson won’t build on his impressive debut. The truly exciting prospect for the Rays is Matt Moore. Last season, Moore came up and dominated the Yankees in his first start: 5 IP, 11 SO, 1 BB, 0 runs. He was the first pitcher to have that many SOs in 5 innings against the Yankees. Moore’s second start was in the playoffs against Texas where he once again proved himself: 7 IP, 6 SO, 2 hits, 0 runs. He’s only 22 years old. Moore could dominate for years to come.

Projected rotation:

  1. Price
  2. Shields
  3. Hellickson
  4. Moore
  5. Jeff Niemann

Red Sox

The Red Sox pitching staff’s season was tainted by its historic September collapse. There’s no way around that simple fact. Whether or not the “chicken and beer” embarrassment really had any effect on the field doesn’t really matter at this point. The reality is fans think it made a difference, and Bobby Valentine felt the need to ban beer from the clubhouse. The Red Sox do have a solid if flawed pitching staff. Josh Beckett put up great numbers last season. He went 13-7, with a 2.89 ERA and 170 SOs. Beckett may not come out and say it, but he has something to prove this season. Even with those solid numbers, the already intense Boston pressure will be amped up on Beckett this season. Look for another strong season from Beckett but one where he pitches well right up to his final start. Jon Lester was Beckett’s partner in crime last season. Lester said he wanted to concentrate on “being a better teammate and having a better presence.” He went on to say, “I care a lot about my job. I hope the fans realize that stuff had nothing to do with what happened on the field. I stunk. We stunk and we’re looking forward to proving people wrong.” His numbers were slightly down from his norm in 2011: 15-9, a 3.47 ERA in only 191.2 innings pitched. It was the first time as a regular starter he failed to reach 200 innings. Like Beckett, look for Lester to rededicate himself and improve on his 2011 season. Clay Buchholz lost the majority his 2011 to injury and pitched only 82.2 innings. Because he was largely absent last year, it’s easy to forget just how electric he was in 2010, where he a posted a 17-7 record, with a 2.33 ERA and made the All-Star team. Much of the Red Sox success in 2012 hinges on whether Buchholz can match his 2010 numbers. Red Sox management is banking on Daniel Bard making the transition from set-up man to starter. If Bard can’t match his eighth-inning effectiveness as a starter, the Red Sox rotation begins to look to very thin. The fifth spot in the rotation is the big battle of the spring. Vicente Padilla, Carlos Silva and Aaron Cook will try to pitch their way into the rotation. Alfredo Aceves may make an appearance, but his value out the bullpen may be too great to limit him to only pitching every five games.

Projected rotation:

  1. Beckett
  2. Lester
  3. Buchholz
  4. Bard
  5. Padilla/Silva/Cook

Blue Jays

Ricky Romero is the ace of Toronto’s staff. He went 15-11, with a 2.92 ERA in 225 innings pitched. Romero has improved every season since his debut in 2009. He’s a sure thing for Toronto, and it’s exciting to see what kind of numbers he will put up entering the prime of his career. Brandon Morrow is a solid number-two pitcher behind Romero. He has great stuff and should be able to improve on his 4.72 ERA from last season. Any team would be happy to have a number-two starter who is capable of striking over 200 batters. Brett Cecil had a horrible 2011, going 4-11 with a 4.73 ERA. But Cecil did show signs of his potential with two CGs and pitching a four-hit shutout against the Rangers last July. Henderson Alvarez is the prospect to watch in Toronto’s 2012 rotation. In 10 starts last season, Alvarez struck out 40 batters and only walked eight. Alvarez is only 21 years old and provides excellent end-of-the-rotation depth. Kyle Drabek seems poised to start the year as Toronto’s fifth starter. He is more potential than reality at this point, but Toronto will give him a shot to start the year.

Projected rotation:

  1. Romero
  2. Morrow
  3. Cecil
  4. Alvarez
  5. Drabek


It didn’t get any worse than the starting rotation for the Baltimore Orioles last season. They had the worst ERA in baseball at 5.39. Their pitchers couldn’t eat up innings and their “ace” lost 17 games. They may not be much better in 2012. Jeremy Guthrie was traded, and this is now a team with no opening day starter. That job may fall to Zach Britton, who went 11-11, with a 4.61 ERA in 154.1 innings pitched. While his health is a question mark, Britton is only 24 years old and has upside. Tommy Hunter is another candidate for opening-day starter. It remains to be seen if Hunter can repeat his 2010 success when he posted a 13-4 record, with a 3.73 ERA in 128 innings pitched. Like Britton, Baltimore fans have to rely on Hunter’s upside for a dose of excitement. Wei-Yin Chen is interesting because he’ll be a mystery until we see what he can do against major league hitters. He never had an ERA above 2.90 in Japan but how that will change when pitching in the AL East remains to be seen.

Projected rotation:

  1. Britton
  2. Hunter
  3. Chen
  4. Jason Hammel
  5. Jake Arrieta/Chris Tillman/Brian Matusz

There are question marks on every staff.  But questions are the beauty of spring. There are always surprises and the 2012 spring will prove no different.

Contributor: Brian Hendrickson


Post By Thomas Fitzgerald (13 Posts)

Thomas Fitzgerald is the assistant editor for the online magazine Pigeon Town. He lives in Watertown, MA. Brian Hendrickson is a life long Red Sox fan working in Boston who falls asleep dreaming of baseball stats. He spends his free time analyzing video and reading every possible rumor.

Website: →



Must Read Columns

Through The Fence Baseball
Through The Fence Sports Corp at Intern Sushi.Apply to our Internships