Fantasy baseball starting pitcher rankings for week 9

These fantasy baseball starting pitcher rankings were pulled Friday morning. Please be aware the matchups are subject to change. The data is up to date as of Thursday night.

Top starters

Rank	Name	Team	Opp.	ERA	K%	BB%
1	Zack Greinke	LAD	CIN, PIT	2.01	27.4%	5.9%
2	Yu Darvish	TEX	@MIN, @WSH	2.35	28.4%	7.6%
3	Max Scherzer	DET	@OAK, @SEA	2.59	29.3%	8.3%
4	Johnny Cueto	CIN	@LAD, @ARI	1.86	28.4%	6.2%
5	Cole Hamels	PHI	COL, NYM	4.30	24.8%	8.1%
6	Sonny Gray	OAK	DET, LAA	1.99	20.0%	8.4%
7	Yordano Ventura	KC	HOU, @TOR	2.80	24.9%	7.1%
8	Jeff Samardzija	CHC	@SF, @MIL	1.46	19.9%	7.7%
9	Michael Wacha	STL	NYY, SF	2.54	26.4%	6.8%
10	Ervin Santana	ATL	BOS, @MIA	3.42	22.5%	6.6%
11	Clayton Kershaw	LAD	CIN	4.44	29.8%	3.2%
12	Adam Wainwright	STL	SF	1.85	23.6%	5.4%
13	Masahiro Tanaka	NYY	MIN	2.39	29.1%	3.2%
14	Chris Sale	CWS	CLE	1.89	31.7%	5.7%
15	Julio Teheran	ATL	@MIA	1.92	19.7%	6.6%
16	Corey Kluber	CLE	COL	3.42	26.4%	5.4%
17	Madison Bumgarner	SF	@STL	3.37	25.0%	6.5%
18	Hisashi Iwakuma	SEA	DET	1.76	16.5%	1.8%
19	Felix Hernandez	SEA	LAA	2.94	23.6%	4.7%
20	Stephen Strasburg	WSH	TEX	3.38	28.2%	6.1%
21	James Shields	KC	@TOR	2.67	21.2%	4.7%
22	Jordan Zimmermann	WSH	MIA	3.70	20.6%	4.8%
23	Homer Bailey	CIN	@LAD	5.44	20.1%	7.9%
24	David Price	TB	@BOS	4.29	26.6%	2.1%
25	A.J. Burnett	PHI	NYM	3.32	19.3%	11.6%
26	Justin Verlander	DET	@SEA	3.55	17.1%	9.4%

Additional information: Before the season started, I was not buying Zack Greinke. I thought he had a higher risk of injury because he dealt with elbow problems last year and he stopped throwing his slider last year. The slider puts a lot of strain on the elbow, so I inferred that he was hiding an elbow problem. However, it turns out he consciously decided to throw the slider less in an effort to have a long successful career. I no longer believe he is a high risk for injury and is a fantasy ace. Scott Spratt cited recently the Indians are the worst defensive team in baseball. For the year, Corey Kluber has a 3.43 ERA, 1.29 WHIP and 2.72 xFIP. The vast majority of the time, I never put much weight into FIP and xFIP because the statistics are both inherently flawed, but I cited it this time to show how good he has been despite the defense. Kluber is a must-start regardless of matchup. Ervin Santana has not looked good in his past two starts as he has allowed 11 earned runs, 19 hits and five walks in 12 innings. The hit type distribution (ground ball, fly ball, etc), WHAV (well hit average) and contact rates are all nearly identical to his first six starts of the year. I’m still a believer.

Backend starters

Rank	Name	Team	Opp.	ERA	K%	BB%
27	Matt Cain	SF	CHC, @STL	3.66	20.0%	8.7%
28	Lance Lynn	STL	NYY, SF	3.60	22.6%	7.7%
29	Nathan Eovaldi	MIA	@WSH, ATL	3.41	20.2%	5.1%
30	Tyson Ross	SD	@ARI, @CWS	2.64	22.8%	9.7%
31	Jon Lester	BOS	@ATL, TB	3.36	27.8%	6.6%
32	Kyle Lohse	MIL	BAL, CHC	2.67	19.9%	4.8%
33	Jered Weaver	LAA	@SEA, @OAK	2.85	19.2%	7.3%
34	Jon Niese	NYM	PIT, @PHI	2.70	18.6%	6.5%
35	Drew Smyly	DET	@OAK, @SEA	2.98	23.1%	10.0%
36	Tim Hudson	SF	CHC, @STL	2.13	16.0%	2.5%
37	Drew Hutchison	TOR	TB, KC	3.45	23.9%	7.3%
38	Alfredo Simon	CIN	@LAD, @ARI	2.32	15.5%	6.0%
39	Hyun-Jin Ryu	LAD	CIN, PIT	3.00	20.8%	6.3%
40	Gerrit Cole	PIT	@LAD	3.83	21.4%	7.3%
41	Alex Cobb	TB	@TOR	1.40	20.6%	7.2%
42	Mike Minor	ATL	@BOS	3.80	20.8%	5.9%
43	Doug Fister	WSH	TEX	3.93	16.7%	1.3%
44	Garrett Richards	LAA	@OAK	2.90	23.1%	9.2%
45	Dan Haren	LAD	PIT	3.17	17.1%	3.8%
46	Dallas Keuchel	HOU	BAL	2.92	22.7%	5.0%
47	Trevor Bauer	CLE	COL	2.25	26.0%	10.0%
48	Wily Peralta	MIL	CHC	2.18	18.2%	5.8%
49	Jesse Chavez	OAK	DET	2.54	24.7%	6.5%
50	Anibal Sanchez	DET	@OAK	2.89	23.3%	12.1%
51	Rick Porcello	DET	@OAK	2.90	16.3%	3.5%

Additional information: Tyson Ross will always be subject to the random blow-up start because he can lose command of the strike zone randomly, but I have no hesitation in starting him in two-start week in hitter friendly ballparks because he’s striking out 26.4 percent batters in his last four starts and has a 22.8 percent strikeout rate for the year. Also, the White Sox matchup is not as scary as it look as Jose Abreu will not be playing. In his last four starts, Gerrit Cole has a 4.74 ERA, 1.42 WHIP and a 25.2 percent strikeout rate. However, that has come with a .368 BABIP. I’m still a believer in Cole’s ceiling, and he’s still a must-start because the BABIP will regress.

Spot starters

Rank	Name	Team	Opp.	ERA	K%	BB%
52	C.J. Wilson	LAA	@SEA	3.16	24.6%	8.5%
53	Jose Quintana	CWS	CLE, SD	3.67	19.2%	6.3%
54	Brandon McCarthy	ARI	SD, CIN	4.67	21.2%	4.6%
55	Wade Miley	ARI	SD, CIN	4.85	18.1%	8.7%
56	Tanner Roark	WSH	MIA, TEX	3.42	18.4%	6.6%
57	Tyler Skaggs	LAA	@SEA, @OAK	4.14	16.4%	5.9%
58	Travis Wood	CHC	@MIL	4.61	21.2%	7.5%
59	Hiroki Kuroda	NYY	@STL	4.61	18.7%	3.9%
60	Scott Kazmir	OAK	DET	2.39	20.4%	5.7%
61	Chris Archer	TB	@TOR	4.59	18.6%	9.0%
62	John Lackey	BOS	ATL	4.01	22.9%	5.3%
63	Yovani Gallardo	MIL	CHC	3.51	16.4%	7.6%
64	Jason Hammel	CHC	@MIL	2.91	21.7%	5.8%
65	Jordan Lyles	COL	@PHI	3.50	15.7%	9.0%
66	Jake Arrieta	CHC	@SF	2.33	23.5%	10.6%
67	Edwin Jackson	CHC	@SF	3.98	21.4%	8.7%
68	Shelby Miller	STL	NYY	2.79	18.2%	13.2%
69	Mike Leake	CIN	@ARI	2.91	14.8%	4.7%
70	Josh Beckett	LAD	PIT	2.89	23.8%	8.8%
71	Chris Tillman	BAL	@MIL, @HOU	4.21	17.3%	9.0%
72	Henderson Alvarez	MIA	@WSH	3.21	14.5%	6.1%
73	Tony Cingrani	CIN	@ARI	3.76	23.9%	12.3%
74	Phil Hughes	MIN	TEX, @NYY	3.15	20.9%	2.7%

Additional information: After a brutal start to the season, Phil Hughes has quietly been one of the best pitchers in baseball (in terms of ERA) in his last five starts. In those starts, he has a 21 percent strikeout rate and has not allowed a walk (not a misprint). His next start is home to the Rangers, which, before the season began, looked like a start you should stay away from. However, this is not the same Rangers offense of the past four to five years; the Rangers are only 13th in the majors in wOBA. The start in New York scares me, which is why he is ranked this low. Chris Tillman is dealing with a mild groin injury, and the early grumblings Friday morning could have his Monday start pushed back. The latest reports are he’ll pitch on Monday, but be warned. The groin issue was reported on May 13, but following that report, he went ahead and threw shut out against the Royals. After the start, I didn’t think much of the injury, but it was obvious there was something wrong on Wednesday; his fastball velocity was 88-90 mph, and he had no command of any of his pitches and the pitches he threw for strikes were basically batting practice fastballs. I have no idea what Tillman we’re getting next week. I’m huge believer in Jake Arrieta’s stuff and his ultimate fantasy ceiling as a top 20-25 starting pitcher. He looked fantastic in his last start in San Diego (who doesn’t have a good starts against the Padres?) and, most importantly, he threw season high 94 pitches. In his previous three starts, he only threw 81-82 pitches. If he can throw 95-plus pitches, he’ll pitch deep enough into games to earn wins. His next starts are: at the Giants, home to the Mets, home to the Marlins, at the Phillies and then at the Marlins. Go add him now because all of those starts are stream-worthy in leagues as shallow as 12-team mixed leagues.

Proceed with caution

Rank	Name	Team	Opp.	ERA	K%	BB%
75	Miguel Gonzalez	BAL	@HOU	4.53	21.0%	7.5%
76	Jacob deGrom	NYM	PIT, @PHI	2.77	20.8%	10.4%
77	Mark Buehrle	TOR	TB, KC	2.16	14.7%	6.6%
78	Collin McHugh	HOU	@KC, BAL	3.32	27.0%	7.9%
79	Danny Duffy	KC	HOU	1.42	19.0%	10.0%
80	Drew Pomeranz	OAK	LAA	0.94	24.3%	9.0%
81	Tom Koehler	MIA	@WSH	2.25	16.2%	10.5%
82	Ian Kennedy	SD	@CWS	3.79	25.9%	5.5%
83	Justin Masterson	CLE	@CWS	5.32	18.9%	10.7%
84	Marco Estrada	MIL	BAL	3.65	22.9%	7.3%
85	Chase Whitley	NYY	@STL, MIN	1.00	18.4%	7.9%

Additional Information: If you remove the first outlier, starter Collin McHugh has a 4.02 ERA, 1.15 WHIP, 22.3 percent strikeout rate and 9.2 percent walk rate. With those peripherals, the ERA should be in the 3.50-3.80 range, and those are the numbers I expect from him the rest of the year. The Orioles matchup is not ideal, but I love the Royals matchup as they are 25th in the majors in wOBA. Eventually, the walks are going to come back to haunt Drew Pomeranz.

Avoid

Rank	Name	Team	Opp.	ERA	K%	BB%
86	Brandon Cumpton	PIT	@NYM, @LAD	4.25	17.3%	1.9%
87	Francisco Liriano	PIT	@LAD	4.86	22.3%	10.1%
88	Zack Wheeler	NYM	@PHI	4.53	20.9%	11.8%
89	David Phelps	NYY	@STL	3.18	22.0%	10.0%
90	Roenis Elias	SEA	LAA, DET	3.68	21.1%	10.2%
91	Jake Odorizzi	TB	@BOS	4.99	26.7%	11.8%
92	Chase Anderson	ARI	SD	5.05	19.0%	7.1%
93	Bartolo Colon	NYM	PIT	5.34	17.3%	2.4%
94	Brad Peacock	HOU	@KC	5.20	21.5%	14.6%
95	Ubaldo Jimenez	BAL	@HOU	4.50	21.1%	10.1%
96	R.A. Dickey	TOR	KC	4.20	18.9%	11.3%
97	Matt Garza	MIL	BAL	4.93	17.9%	8.4%
98	Clay Buchholz	BOS	@ATL, TB	6.32	15.4%	7.0%
99	Ricky Nolasco	MIN	TEX	5.49	15.2%	6.2%
100	Aaron Harang	ATL	BOS, @MIA	3.32	25.9%	7.3%
101	Gavin Floyd	ATL	@BOS	2.41	21.0%	6.2%

Additional information: Chase Anderson has suffered from some bad luck due to the long ball and doesn’t have elite upside, but this is a guy who will get batters out fairly consistently. Also, when in doubt, I’ll take pitchers who pitch against the Padres. Brandon Cumpton is my favorite player in this tier because he doesn’t walk hitters and throws strikes.