The Bronx Breeze: There’s Mariano … and everyone else


Mariano Rivera is the all-time leader in post-game handshakes. (Nick Laham/Getty Images)

This past weekend, I took my first visit to Citi Field. Overall, I liked the ballpark. The difference in atmosphere at Yankees and Mets games is definitely noticeable, despite the fact that the Phillies were in Queens for a three-game set. However, I got into a deep discussion with my friends from Penn State about closers. I wish to share the gist of that with you all.

The Phillies and Mets entered the ninth inning tied 3-3. Francisco Rodriguez began his run from the bullpen to the mound, and I was excited to see him pitch in person for the first time in years. He didn’t exactly measure up to my expectations. After throwing 18 pitches, he managed to surrender five hits, three runs and only record two outs in the process. Tim Byrdak had to be called upon to stop the bleeding.

As Yankees fans, we’ve been absolutely spoiled since a certain someone took over the helm in 1997. Mariano Rivera is truly one of a kind. Think about it, he has been so good that everyone is genuinely surprised when he blows a save. And the fact that opposing teams have yet to figure him out after 17 years is mind-blowing.

Rivera primarily throws two pitches: a fastball and a cutter. These pitches travel, on average, at approximately the same velocity as one another (90-91 mph). However, his cutter moves in on left-handed hitters and away from right-handed hitters and Rivera lives on the inside and outside parts of home plate.

Let’s take a look at some of the most notable closers over the past five years (2006-2010) and their stats for innings pitched/saves/blown saves/converted save opportunity percentage and ERA.

 


Innings


Saves

Blown
Saves


Save %


ERA

Mariano Rivera

343.1

180

15

92.3

1.99

Jonathan Papelbon

331.0

188

25

88.3

2.18

Francisco Rodriguez

334.0

209

29

87.8

2.53

Bobby Jenks

302.1

167

24

87.4

3.48

Jose Valverde

302.2

160

25

86.5

3.36

Francisco Cordero

348.1

179

36

83.3

3.23

Brad Lidge

315.2

150

30

83.3

4.16

Huston Street

299.2

126

30

80.8

3.33

Here are some quick conclusions I can draw from this chart. First of all, these are eight of the most consistent closers over the past five years that I can find (yeah, I realize that they aren’t exactly perfect examples) with 300 innings of closing, which averages out to 60 innings per year. Over that time period, Rivera has proven to be the most reliable in converting his save opportunities into saves. He’s pitched more innings than anyone except Cordero , and blown less saves than anyone listed. Sure, there are variables on how large of a lead each pitcher’s team had when entering into the save opportunity. But Rivera has come on and easily done his job more effectively than any other closer over the past five years. The sad part is that Mariano was more dominant from 2001-2005, compiling a WAR of 13.0 (compared to a WAR of 11.4 from 2006-2010). To chart the past 10 seasons would be nearly impossible due to the fact that teams simply don’t have a guy that’s been closing for that long.

He’s repeated the same effortless motion, flawlessly, thousands of times. He’s never suffered a serious injury and is a true gentleman. I was at the game last Wednesday when he made his 1,000th career appearance in a baseball game. The fans gave a nice round of applause, as they should have. And thankfully, there will be more appearances to follow.
The bottom line is that it’s very difficult to find a closer that has longevity. Teams are lucky to get a guy for five years that produces numbers that are similar to anyone on that chart above. The thing is, those numbers simply aren’t good enough for Yankees fans. It’s going to be a tremendously harsh wake-up call when Rivera is no longer pitching in the ninth inning. I feel bad for whoever takes over for him, because they’ll be unfairly compared to the greatest that has ever lived.

My advice: Take advantage of all the opportunities you have to see Rivera in person or on television. Enjoy the ride, because it’s going to be over before you know it.

Weekly prediction: Last week, I incorrectly predicted Derek Jeter getting four extra base hits by Monday (he only had one). However, he’s been hitting the ball with authority! This week, I’ll go with the Yankees winning a regular season series out in Anaheim for the first time since September of 2009.

 


Innings


Saves

Blown
Saves


Save %


ERA

Mariano Rivera

343.1

180

15

92.3

1.99

Jonathan Papelbon

331.0

188

25

88.3

2.18

Francisco Rodriguez

334.0

209

29

87.8

2.53

Bobby Jenks

302.1

167

24

87.4

3.48

Jose Valverde

302.2

160

25

86.5

3.36

Francisco Cordero

348.1

179

36

83.3

3.23

Francisco Cordero

348.1

179

36

83.3

3.23

Huston Street

299.2

126

30

80.8

3.33

comments

4 Comments

Your email address will not be published.

  1. How does Joe Nathan look against these numbers? Bobby Jerks shouldn’t have been put in this conversation. 22 BS 202 S 90 % save rate (if I did that right.) 344 innings. 74 ER is a 1.94 ERA. All of this while missing the 2010 season.

  2. I’ve mentioned this before — and by no means do I mean any disrespect to Mo (I love him) — but he’s an example of a pitcher who is perfect for his role. Imagine how effective that cutter would (or wouldn’t be) if batters faced it a 3-4 times a game if Rivera was a starter. Not sure he would be nearly as dominant. But seeing that nasty cutter bust in on leftys and force righties to wave as it breaks down and away for only one at-bat makes it extremely effective. Think about it, the guy has no off-speed stuff, and has lasted nearly 20 years — and dominated in the process! Unthinkable … yet, pure Mo. I bow to thee.

  3. The folks of Yankeeville will sorely miss Rivers when the ride is over and they get an average closer.

DON'T MISS