Castillo to Phillies: Good news or bad news?

Everyone is wondering when Chase Utley will return to the Phillies lineup. (AP Photo/Gene J. Puskar)

Luis Castillo gives good glove. As for offense, um, not so much. Which is a good sign for the also-ran Braves, Marlins, Mets and Senators in the NL East. Pre-ordained “best-team-ever” Philadelphia’s signing of Castillo yesterday adds depth at second until Chase Utley‘s return — assuming he comes back anytime soon. The Castillo signing should have Phils phans pheeling phunky because it indicates Utley’s injury may be more troublesome than initially thought.

With Jayson Werth counting bank in Washington and the re-boot of Dominic Brown temporarily on hold due to injury, losing Utley for an extended period could impact run production, especially if Jimmy Rollins and Ryan Howard spend time on the DL or struggle through extended slumps. Without Utley’s bat, the starting rotation will have even more pressure to limit opposing teams to fewer runs per game. No matter how good your starting rotation is, you still need to score runs.

So, what do you think? Will an extended stay on the DL for Utley impact the Phillies’ chances to win the NL East? How do they make up for Utley’s production?


Related Articles


  1. Phillies survived DL trips by Rollins, Howard and Utley last year, and still won, so you have to give credit to the rest of the lineup for picking up the slack. BUT, Werth was a key ingredient. He’s gone and that could create a challenge as the season unfolds. Phils have the oldest team in the NL, too. So, breakdowns are possible along the way. Will be an interesting season to say the least.

  2. I don’t think anyone in the NL East is frowning on this move, but maybe the Phillies are. If this is what they have in mind to supplement the loss of Utley, then they have lost their mind. Everyone is already saying their lineup is less potent this year and with the potential loss of utley, I really think they could be in trouble offensively.

Leave a Reply

Back to top button